Debt

When Credit Counseling Isn’t An Option

Posted by Jean

If your debt is overwhelming you, my first suggestion is always to contact the National Foundation for Credit Counseling. They can very often hook you up with a member credit counselor, who will put you on a debt management plan that allows you to pay off your debt within three to five years.

I mentioned this a few weeks ago, and dljimerson left the following comment:

In my case, I went to NFCC, filled out their requested info on CC bills etc (I owe about 50K in CC and car payments). I am unemployed and have been for months now, blown through whatever savings I have and unemployment covers the bare minimum to sustain life. The response from NFCC was I should seek legal assistance – which means bankruptcy. NFCC sure didn’t help me with their DMP plan. What else can I do? Is a bankruptcy my only option?

Let me just say that I’ve heard this from other people, and the fact is, no solution works for everyone. I’m guessing that the form you’re referring to, dljimerson, is the one you filled out when you reached out to a counselor. Although one of the main goals of NFCC is to keep people out of bankruptcy, sometimes, that’s just not possible. A credit counselor won’t recommend a debt management plan if it’s not appropriate for your financial situation, because that would be of no help to you. Because you have a significant debt load, and you’re unemployed, it wouldn’t be realistic to put you on a repayment plan that you won’t be able to complete.

Gail Cunningham, my go-to resource at NFCC, says that about a third of the people who come to them are put on a debt management plan. The other two thirds either use the advice of a counselor to get out of debt on their own, or are referred to a social service agency (if they have significant issues affecting their financial situation, like gambling or drug/alcohol abuse) or to legal options like bankruptcy.

Bankruptcy is a serious financial decision, and I’ve said time and time again that’s it’s a last resort. So I’d start by calling your creditors, if you haven’t done that already, and explaining the situation. They may be willing to work with you by lowering your monthly payments or settling your debt for less than you owe. If that doesn’t work, then yes, it’s time to seriously consider bankruptcy. You may find that a fresh start is exactly what you need. While it will, of course, negatively affect your credit score, but your score has likely already started to fall. If you stay on track after filing, you should be able to climb back fairly easily. In fact, many people begin receiving credit card offers in the mail again after about two years.

COMMENTS | 3 comments so far

  1. 1

    Jean,

    I was working with a credit counseling agency for a year, but was unable to maintain the payments. I am self employed and experienced a drop off in income after the stock market crash. I’m starting to see an improvement in my business, but have not made any credit card payments for about six months. I’m starting to negotiate with the banks, but many of them will not offer any plans to reduce my interest rate or have sold my account to a collection company. What is your advice for settlement plans and negotiations with collection agencies? Do you know how long my credit report and score would be affected by settlements?

    Thanks,

    Chad

  2. 2

    Jean,

    I am about 25K in debt. I was on track paying down my debt until I got myself into a marriage prematurely with someone who is highly controlling, has a very poor financial history and who looked at the income I made as “extra play money”. As a result, I started missing payments to my creditors and then got so overwhelmed that I was too afraid to deal with my creditors to try to work something out with each of them. I defaulted on several credit cards. I have received offers to settle for less than owed on the accounts, but was not able to come up with the lump sums that they wanted. Now one creditor has put a judgement for approximately 5k against a condo of mine and I have been served with papers from another. The local Budget and Credit Counseling center said they could not help me. I did consult an bankruptcy attorney, but I’d rather try to pay these off rather than file for bankruptcy. What would you suggest the best course of action would be for my situation?

    Thanks!!

    Maria

  3. 3

    I finally went with the DMP after trying unsuccessfully to handle my credit problem on my own, now I’ve just been told that I will be geing an$800 a month pay cut. I can still make the payment on my DMP, but I don’t see how I’ll be able to make my car payment or buy groceries. I already have a second job, I’ve been trying to cut expenses (which is hard since I don’t drink coffee, and have been packing y lunch for years). I’m going thru all my “stuff” to see what I can sell on ebay. I really really don’t want to go bankrupt, but somedays I just don’t see how I can’t……


Do you have something to say?

We'd love to have you share your ideas. First, please sign in

If you are not already a member, why not go ahead and become a member now?